ATTOM’s Property Reports include the ability to find and filter comps—including private sales— based on location, date, price, and and a range of property attributes.
Sign Up NowProperty Report for 4538 Main St, Conestoga, PA 17516
Find Comparables
View Map Layers
Subscribe to unlock map layers including flood zones and tax parcels
Property Details
- Property Address 4538 Main St, Conestoga, PA 17516
- County Lancaster
- Parcel ID 120-65891-0-0000
- Legal description DIST:120 CITY/MUNI/TWP:CONESTOGA TWP
- School district Penn Manor School District
- Acreage 5.5
- Property class Single Family Residence
- Zoning Subscribe
- Square footage 3,734
- Year built 1725
- Bedrooms 4
- Bathrooms 3
About the Property
4538 Main St is a single family residence in the city of Conestoga, PA 17516. Located in the Penn Manor School District, which resides in Lancaster County, PA and built in 1725. This Single Family Residence sits on a 239,580 sq ft lot and features 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms and 3,734 sq ft of living space.
The most recent property tax for 4538 Main St was $10,843 with an estimated market value range of $980,256 to $1,083,441. This property was last sold on August 05, 2013 for $575,000.
Property Info
Sign up to see full Property Info for 4538 Main St, Conestoga
Flood
Legal
- DIST:120 CITY/MUNI/TWP:CONESTOGA TWP
- Classification SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE
- County LANCASTER
- FIPS 42071
- Civil Division CONESTOGA
- Census 420710139.022013
- Parcel ID 120-65891-0-0000
- Neighborhood N/A
- Tract 0
- Secondary School District N/A
- Primary School District Penn Manor School District
Ownership
Land
- Acres 5.5
- Square Feet 239,580
Building
- Units N/A
- Year Built 1725
- Effective Year Built N/A
- Stories 2
- # Fireplaces 1
- Garage/Carport N/A
Utilities
- Cooling N/A
- Heating Hot Water
Interior
- Square Footage
- Living Area 3,734
- Total Rooms 8
- Bedrooms 4
- Total Bathrooms 3
- Full Bathrooms 2
Your Property Report will also include the following information:
How can you use ATTOM Property Reports?
Real Estate Agents
Power up your client responsiveness, productivity, and transaction speed with the most comprehensive data.
Investors
Make faster decisions based on extensive property information that includes purchasing, selling, listing, and mortgage data.
Appraisers
Comparative market analysis facilitates credible valuations that will move inventory and ease transactions.
Homeowners/buyers
Discover how much your home or prospective home is worth and compare to nearby houses
Try before you buy— examine our free sample report and all the rich data it contains.
Start Free TrialConestoga Residential Market Stats
Median Sale Price
$310,000
-1.6% YoY
Median Price/sq ft.
$171
Lancaster County Median Sale Price
$310,000
-1.6% YoY
See more Real Estate Trends for Conestoga including home values, types of properties sold and transaction volumes.
Taxes and Assessments for 4538 Main St, Conestoga
| Tax Year | Taxes | Tax Assesed Value | Exemptions |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $10,843 (+2.5%) | $487,200 | |
| 2024 | $10,581 (+1.9%) | $487,200 | |
| 2023 | $10,380 | $487,200 | |
| 2022 | |||
| 2021 | |||
| 2020 | |||
| 2019 |
Sales History for 4538 Main St, Conestoga
The most recent sale on 4538 Main St took place on Aug 02, 2013 and recorded on Aug 05, 2013 for $575,000.
Sign up for full access to the complete sales history including potential flips, distressed sales and buyer and seller data.
| Sale Date | Recorded Date | Buyer(s) | Seller(s) | Price | Document ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Recently Sold Comparables
These are nearby recently sold properties that are similar to this property, base on available data.
| Address | Distance | SqFt | Sale Date | Price | $/SqFt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1243 LONG LN | 2.98 mi | 2,978 | 04/16/2025 | $1,700,000 | $571 |
| 961 BRENEMAN RD | 2.95 mi | 3,250 | 03/13/2025 | $483,330 | $149 |
| 3456 MAIN ST | 1.89 mi | 4,038 | 01/29/2025 | $585,000 | $145 |
Our Property Reports contain multiple Automated Valuation Models showing low, median, and high values along with confidence scores.
Sign up to access
Sign up to access
Find the Most Accurate Comparables
Nearby Cities
- 1. Conestoga
- 2. Millersville
- 3. Pequea
- 4. Washington Boro
- 5. Brogue
- 6. Willow Street
Various data sets have been provided by a third party or government source and are subject to change and possible errors. Depending on location and source, data may be missing or not available. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed to be accurate, up-to-date, or complete. Buyers, investors, and others are responsible for verifying the accuracy of all information.